Cleaning & Restoration Breaking News

Many Economists Say 'Offshoring' Effect Overblown

March 12, 2004
/ Print / Reprints /
/ Text Size+
NEW YORK (Dow Jones Business News) -- Many economists admit they are stumped by the question of why the expanding U.S. economy isn't churning out many new jobs, as it did so reliably in the late 1990s. But the latest monthly survey of 55 economists by The Wall Street Journal's online edition shows that most agree on one point: "Offshoring" isn't the prime culprit.

Only 16% of those responding said the movement of U.S. jobs to overseas locations has had a significant effect on U.S. job growth, while 39% said it has had a "meaningful but not significant impact" and 43% said it has had little or no impact. Despite the perplexingly weak job growth, the economists also are sticking to their forecasts that the economy will continue to grow at a healthy pace this year, though they think the Federal Reserve will put off thoughts of jacking up interest rates.

Underscoring their expectations about overall economic growth, the Commerce Department reported that retail store sales increased 0.6% in February from the month before on a seasonally adjusted basis.

Meanwhile, sales in January and December were revised higher. The February increase reflected a 2.7% jump in sales at motor vehicles and parts dealers, the largest advance in that category since last March. However, demand in other categories was mixed, leaving sales excluding autos unchanged from a month earlier. That point troubled some economists, who were expecting an increase.

On balance, economists said the latest batch of sales data was consistent with the view that consumer spending has accelerated modestly so far in the first quarter from the fourth-quarter growth rate of 2.7%. That, in turn, is leading most forecasters to maintain their estimates of overall economic growth, despite a lackluster pace of job growth that eventually could become a drain on household spending power.

The survey of economists, conducted late last week and early this week, showed the nation's gross domestic product - a broad measure of the output of goods and services - is expected to grow at a 4.5% annual rate in the first quarter. The economy is expected to grow at a 4.4% rate during the second quarter, 4.1% during the third quarter and 4% during the fourth.

"The consumer is on a good solid track. It is not booming, but it is a good solid track," said Richard Rippe, chief economist of Prudential Equity Group. On average, the economists estimated that the number of U.S. jobs lost by movement of operations overseas since 2001 has been 188,000 in the services sector and 502,000 in manufacturing, for a total of 690,000. That's a small fraction of the 58.6 million in overall layoffs that companies undertook between 2001 and 2003. The vast majority of those layoffs were offset by new hiring elsewhere in the economy, but on a net basis, payroll levels declined by 2.3 million during this period.

Gail Fosler, chief economist for the Conference Board, an association representing global companies, argued that outsourcing is being blown out of proportion in headlines and political debates. While some jobs are being shipped abroad, she noted, others are coming back home or are being created in the U.S. by foreign companies.

The slow job growth has persuaded the economists that the Federal Reserve will try to encourage business investment and hiring by waiting longer before raising its target for short-term interest rates from the current 1%, a 45-year low.

In the latest survey, 50% of the economists think the first rise in the Fed's target rate will come after August. A month ago, only 29% of the economists responding to the survey thought the Fed would hold off that long. On average, the economists think the target rate will stand at 1.5% in December, down from the 1.7% average forecast in February's survey.

In another report on the economy, the government Thursday said prices of imported goods grew much more slowly in February than they did the month before. Overall import prices rose 0.4% in February after a 1.5% gain in January. The slowdown reflected smaller increases in prices of both petroleum and non- petroleum products. Export prices rose for a sixth consecutive month, up 0.6%.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to i Cleaning Specialist Magazine.

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

The 2014 Experience Conference and Exhibition

A look in photos at the 2014 Experience Conference and Exhibition, which was held from April 24-26 at the Embassy Suites Convention Center and Spa in Frisco, Texas.

1/27/15 2:00 pm EST

Grow Your Business and Improve Operations with New Payment Technology

Attend this free webinar to learn how new developments in payment technology can help you close more jobs, increase upselling opportunities and improve operations.


While winter is considered the "slow season" for carpet cleaners, it can also be a season of great opportunity. In this episode of The Hitman Advertising Show, John Braun offers advice for keeping revenue consistent during the cold weather months so you're thriving - and not just surviving - the winter.
More Podcasts

ICS Cleaning Specialist Magazine


2014 Nov/Dec

The Nov/Dec ICS features content on how to get better meter readings, a roundtable on truckmount development, neighborhood marketing and more. Also included is the annual Buyer’s Guide and Directory.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Janitorial Work

In addition to residential and commercial carpet cleaning, do you do any janitorial work on the side?
View Results Poll Archive


The Carpet Cleaner's Book of Unlimited Success! (ebook)

Don’t worry about the recession or about your competition.  Now you can be the owner of over 400 ways for carpet cleaning professionals to make more money and get more jobs!

More Products


Director_Buyer.jpgThe premier resource and reference guide for the cleaning and restoration industries.

Click here to view


facebook_40.png twitter_40px.png youtube_40px.png


Truckmount.jpgEquipment listings and specifications from the leading industry manufacturers.

Click here to view