Web Exclusive Features

Mystery Shoppers: Evaluating Your Talent Pool

Once upon a time, I worked at The Body Shop, the green store with the prime location at your local mall that sells perfume oils and lavender body scrub and lip gloss that tastes like mangos. I love The Body Shop products and I was excited to learn the retail game. So, I got a job there.

The Body Shop had an intensive orientation program. New hires learned all about the “Trade Not Aid” program that delivered the cocoa butter hair conditioner. We learned how to apply mascara to a customer without blinding them. And we learned that at least once a month, as often as once a week, we would be “mystery shopped.”

Mystery shopping is a technique for testing customer service. Here is how it works: a professional shopper will stop by the store and…shop. He or she will be incognito, looking like any other shopper. The mystery shopper will submit a written report on his experience. He will indicate if he was greeted with a smile, or ignored. She will report that you offered the accessory item, or neglected to mention the matching bath salts. A mystery shopper may return an item, to test how well the staff responds. A good mystery shop report is essential for your career in retail. Rewards for good performance include a pat on the back, a certificate or a cash or product prize.

As a retail salesperson, I wondered every time I approached a customer, “Is this a mystery shopper?” It impacted my behavior in a positive way. I like serving people and I am a friendly gal…however, I also like being recognized for a job well done.

Mystery shopping is a powerful, positive tool. It can help business owners address customer service challenges, improve training programs and ensure the team is paying attention.

As a small shop owner, do you have any idea how your technician is behaving, home alone with Mrs. Fernwicky?

Scary, isn’t it?

Points of Personal Contact
In our industry, there are two main points of contact with our customers: The person who answers the phone, and the Plumber who knocks on the door.

Mystery shopping the Customer Service Representatives is a no brainer.

It is easy to answer the phone with the approved company greeting every day. It’s just so easy not to. It’s easy to get sloppy with the greeting, to shorten it, to customize it, to abandon it altogether when it gets busy. It is essential to get this point of personal contact absolutely handled at your company. Mrs. Fernwicky deserves the very best reception when she calls. It is of no concern to her that your phones are busy, or the last caller was verbally abusive.

A report card (Image 1)can help you assess your Customer Service Representatives.

Now, mystery shopping your technicians takes a bit more effort. For retailers like The Body Shop, it is pretty simple to send a professional shopper to the store. You would need to arrange an in-home service call set up.

Homegrown vs. Professional service?
You could make an arrangement with a friend who owns another type of home service company. If you have a pal who owns a lawn care company, you could offer to mystery shop each other’s employees.

Put together a checklist to help standardize performance assessments. Do you have certain policies that you hold sacred? For instance, is it required that your Technicians identify the main water shut off valve for each of your customers? Be sure to list the things that matter most to you.

Once you mystery shop one of your Technicians, he is sure to communicate the 10-20 of the mystery shop home to the rest of the team. So, you would have to move the mystery shop location around a bit.

Image 1

If you are comfortable doing it, Radio Shack has what you need to equip the mystery shop homes video recording equipment. Those little, round cameras are not expensive…and are easy to install for someone like you. Does video-taping make you queasy? That’s OK. This step is optional, and not for the feint of heart.

At what point does it make sense to use a professional service? According to Linda Prayer of National Shopping Service (www.nationalshoppingservice.com), “A professional service will give you more objective results.” Also, hiring a professional mystery shopping service makes sure that you actually follow through on the program.

Prayer explained that they can provide video and audio clips of the mystery shop within 48 hours, via email. They also work with you to craft a customized scorecard for technicians and customer service reps. You can also request mystery shops of your competitor. You can record the calls and service visits, only if National Shopping Service keeps the identity of the company private. Or, you can get a written report on your identified competitors.

Basic Mystery Shopping Guidelines
  1. Plan your mystery shopping program before you launch it.
  2. Announce the program to your team and explain the procedures in detail.
  3. You can’t record a mystery shop without your employees’ consent, so put the mystery shop policy in your employee manual. (Of course, you are best served by checking with a local employment law expert.)
  4. Expect some pushback. “You don’t trust me,” is the underlying concern. Do your best to explain that the consequences of one bad apple in your company are just too great to not put a formal assessment system in place to protect your customers. Also, you should approach mystery shopping as a way to help your team improve their performance. If you are serious about creating excellence in your company, this can be a transformational tool.
  5. Make a game of it…and reward good performance generously.
Here’s the Rub
You are not going to do it. You are not going to mystery shop anyone at your company because you are too afraid of what you would discover. You won’t even ride along with your technicians to assess their performance. You know that they will be on their best behavior because you are along, and you are still chicken. Mystery shopping is way out of your league. That’s what I think.

No? Going to prove me wrong? Great. Give me a call when you do. I’ll write an article about your brave adventure.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to i Cleaning Specialist Magazine.

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

The 2014 Experience Conference and Exhibition

A look in photos at the 2014 Experience Conference and Exhibition, which was held from April 24-26 at the Embassy Suites Convention Center and Spa in Frisco, Texas.


Yes, it's only February now - several weeks or months before the thaw depending on where you live - and hopefully this winter has been a profitable one for your business during the historical slow season. But now's also the time to start planning for the busy season - spring - so that you can hit the ground running. In this episode of The Hitman Advertising Show, John Braun shares tips and tricks on how to make this spring your most profitable yet.
More Podcasts

ICS Cleaning Specialist Magazine


2015 March

The March ICS issue features content on cleaning services, green chemistry, encapsulation, terrazzo floors, educating clients and new products.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Janitorial Work

In addition to residential and commercial carpet cleaning, do you do any janitorial work on the side?
View Results Poll Archive


The Carpet Cleaner's Book of Unlimited Success! (ebook)

Don’t worry about the recession or about your competition.  Now you can be the owner of over 400 ways for carpet cleaning professionals to make more money and get more jobs!

More Products


Director_Buyer.jpgThe premier resource and reference guide for the cleaning and restoration industries.

Click here to view


facebook_40.png twitter_40px.png youtube_40px.png


Truckmount.jpgEquipment listings and specifications from the leading industry manufacturers.

Click here to view