Cleaning & Restoration Breaking News

No Asbestos Deal Yet, But Senate Eyes Vote

March 12, 2004
/ Print / Reprints /
/ Text Size+
NEW YORK, March 12-(Investor's Business Daily) -- After almost a year of bitter fighting, the Senate is close to a vote on a landmark multibillion dollar asbestos settlement bill.

Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., wants a late March or early April floor vote, aides say.

But sources involved in talks say key issues remain. A compromise is "a real long shot," said one.

"They're going to have a vote, but I don't know on what," said Jan Amundson, general counsel for the National Association of Manufacturers.

Asbestos is a fire-resistant material widely used into the '70s. Later linked to cancer and other serious health woes, most firms long ago stopped using it. But it's still in some products like brake pads.

Some 730,000 lawsuits for asbestos exposure have been filed, with $70 billion already paid out. A Rand Corp. study estimates at least another $130 billion will be paid absent a congressional deal.

Lawmakers and lobbyists for business, insurers, big labor and trial lawyers have spent months on a deal with little success.

On Wednesday the AFL-CIO blasted the latest plan as "grossly deficient," but will keep talking.

Senate negotiators hope a deadline will force a compromise.

"We simply cannot delay any longer," said Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, last week. "We need to ensure that the truly sick get fairly compensated and compensated in a timely manner."

Hatch's proposal would create a multibillion dollar trust fund jointly funded by insurers and companies facing asbestos litigation. Payments would be made to people suffering from asbestos-related illness based on how sick they are. In return, companies would be shielded from civil liability.

Business and insurers like the trust fund idea. So does Big Labor. All fear that absent a settlement, a tidal wave of asbestos class-action suits will sink many more firms. Litigation has already driven at least 67 firms into bankruptcy.

But trial lawyers have lobbied hard for Democrats to kill the bill. No wonder: The fund is expected to pay out claims on a no-fault basis, largely cutting out lawyers.

The fund's size is a key sticking point. Hatch first proposed $108 billion. Democrats, led by Sen. Pat Leahy, D-Vt., said it wasn't enough. A Senate panel finally OK'd $153 billion. Senate leaders are now mulling $114 billion, sources say.

"Sen. Frist came up with a funding structure in October that business and insurers signed off on," said one lobbyist. "But labor said, 'Whoa, whoa, there are still funding issues here.' "

Also at issue: how business and insurers split the costs, the victim payment scale and what to do after the fund is empty.

"There are 300,000 pending claims. There will not be enough money, much less for the new claims that are expected," said Carlton Carl, spokesman for the American Trial Lawyers Association.

Congressional aides insist progress is being made. "We're optimistic," said one.

But labor says it won't back a fund under $153 billion. Business says $114 billion is too high already. Insurers vow to walk if the deal allows more suits once the fund is exhausted.

"The difficulty here is that it is a very complex proposal, and all of the issues relate to each other," the lobbyist said. "If you pull on one string, all of the others get out of whack. Nothing is agreed to until everything is agreed to."

Asbestos suits have bankrupted 22 firms since 2000. Over 8,400 companies from across the economy have been hit with lawsuits. Bankruptcies have cost 60,000 to 100,00 jobs.

Cases have swelled in recent years despite falling asbestos use. In 2003, a record 100,000 claims were filed. Critics contend many are suspect.

A 2003 American Bar Association study found that most new filings involve people without cancer and suffering no ailments at all.

"Contemporary asbestos litigation is no longer driven solely or even primarily by the occurrence of disabling asbestos-related diseases," the study said.

Trial lawyers dispute that.

"For people to say that someone is not sick because that person is not yet disabled is ridiculous," ATLA's Carl said.

Did you enjoy this article? Click here to subscribe to i Cleaning Specialist Magazine.

You must login or register in order to post a comment.



Image Galleries

The 2014 Experience Conference and Exhibition

A look in photos at the 2014 Experience Conference and Exhibition, which was held from April 24-26 at the Embassy Suites Convention Center and Spa in Frisco, Texas.


Have a limited marketing budget but realize the importance of neighborhood marketing? Try doorknob hangers, a low-cost, yet highly effective way to drum up more business. In this episode, John Braun discusses the value of this tactic as well as what you should include on the materials you're hanging.
More Podcasts

ICS Cleaning Specialist Magazine


2014 September

The September issue of ICS features stories on moisture detection, disinfectant services, neighborhood marketing, then we discuss the last level of being phenomenal, and cool products.

Table Of Contents Subscribe

Social Media

Social media is a good way to regularly keep in touch and interact with current clients and reach potential ones. What social mediums do you use in your cleaning/restoration business?
View Results Poll Archive


Get Paid! book cover
Get Paid! (ebook)
Over 30 authors – over 40 articles…from attorneys, contractors, consultants, instructors and others, both inside and outside the restoration industry. R & R, C & R and Cleanfax, opened their archives and gave us the best they had, other chapters were created just for the “Get Paid!” book and its readers. And every one of them has ideas for how to get paid what you are owed.

More Products


Director_Buyer.jpgThe premier resource and reference guide for the cleaning and restoration industries.

Click here to view


Truckmount.jpgEquipment listings and specifications from the leading industry manufacturers.

Click here to view


facebook_40.png twitter_40px.png youtube_40px.pngcrc logo